• Home
  • /
  • Cat Food
  • /
  • Open Farm Cat Food Review: Ethical, Sustainable Pet Food That Cats Love!

Open Farm Cat Food Review: Ethical, Sustainable Pet Food That Cats Love!

Posted in: Cat Food - Last Updated: January 30, 2023 - Author: Rebekah Carter
Posted in Cat Food 
Last Updated: January 27, 2023  
Author:  Rebekah Carter

Today, we’re taking a closer look at the Open Farm subscription service for cat food, dog food, and treats. With the help of our own furry friends, we’ve tested some of the top-selling products available from the brand, to help give you a behind-the-scenes insight into their pros and cons. 

Choosing the right food and treats for your feline companion can be one of the toughest challenges facing a pet parent. 

open farm cat food

Not only do you need to ensure the ingredients in each meal are cat-friendly, nutritious, and delicious, but you may also want to ensure the food you’re buying adheres to your personal values and expectations. 

As a highly eco-friendly, ethical, and innovative company, Open Farm provides pet parents with everything they need for happier, healthier animals. 

The company also sells everything from comprehensive dry food to delectable treats, available on subscription, to save you time visiting the grocery store. Let’s take a closer look at what you can expect. 

Is Open Farm Cat Food Any Good?


We love the foods available from Open Farm for both our dogs and cats. These delicious meals are clearly made with care, and sourced ethically, which is a huge weight off our minds. So many big positives with this pet food.

About Open Farm: An Introduction to the Brand

Part of what makes Open Farm such a compelling choice for people in search of delicious food options is its fantastic story. The tale of Open Farm begins with the co-founder, Jacqueline Prehogan welcoming a rescue dog named Bella into her home. 

Use code AFF20 for 20% off first auto-ship order!

open farm cat food product

Try this highly rated premium cat food now

Distressed by the number of pet foods on the market filled with unnecessary, untraceable, or filler ingredients, Prehogan decided to create something new, with fresh, ethical resources. 

Partnering with her brother-in-law Derek and husband Isaac, Jacqueline engaged in years of comprehensive research to start her Open Farm brand. Not only did the team prioritize high-quality ingredients in all of their foods, but they altered the manufacturing process too, focusing on concepts like exceptional transparency and meticulous source vetting. 

Open Farm holds its food to the highest standards, focusing on pillars such as:

  • Premium nutrition: Open Farm selects only the highest quality functional ingredients for both cats and dogs. The food provided is designed to offer your animals the best, most nutritious meals, with no antibiotics, hormones, or GMOs.
  • Source vetting: Open Farm only uses ethically sourced ingredients, crucial for any animal lover. All the farms, plants, and facilities used by the company are audited for stringent animal welfare standards. Every animal used in each meal is ethically and humanely raised with no cages, ensuring a good life for everyone. 
  • Transparency: To ensure every customer is comfortable with the ingredients included in their meals, Open Farm commits to exceptional traceability. Consumers can instantly track every ingredient in each Open Farm product back to its original origin. 
  • Climate protection: Not only does Open Farm focus on keeping animals healthy and happy, but they’re committed to making the world a better place too. The company is engaged in a ten-year mission to reduce its carbon footprint and minimize emissions. Even their packaging process is focused on sustainability. 

Open Farm Product Options

Open Farm offers a selection of dry and wet cat foods, as well as dry and wet dog foods, treats, and bone broth for cats. All of the dry formulas consist of real, animal-based protein, crucial to good feline and canine health. They’re also low in carbohydrates, to help reduce weight gain. The wet cat foods are made with 100% human-quality ingredients, with ethically sourced meat in recyclable cartons.

For cats, options include:

  • Dry cat food: Homestead Turkey and Chicken, Whitefish dry, Lamb, or Wild-Caught Salmon: Featuring ethically-raised protein, non-GMO fruits and vegetables such as Chickpeas, pumpkin, cranberries, and coconut oil, and prebiotic fibers. There’s also a kitten-focused recipe made with turkey, whitefish, herring, and chicken.
  • Freeze-dried raw food: Surf & Turf, Chicken, Salmon & Cod, or Salmon & Chicken: Including 100% animal welfare certified protein. Grain-free, legume-free, and high protein ingredients, with nourishing ratios of bone, organs, and meat. 
  • Wet cat food: Chicken rustic blend, Herring and Mackerel or Wild-Caught Salmon: Featuring ethically raised protein, high-quality fruits and vegetables such as carrots, pumpkin, cranberries, spinach, and coconut oils, and no artificial colors or preservatives. There’s also a single protein option for sensitive tummies.
  • Bone broth: Grass-fed Beef, Homestead turkey, or Chicken: Including ethically-raised protein sources, nutritious vegetables and fruits like pumpkin, and carrots, and minimal fat. All ingredients are human-grade and gently simmered in small batches.

Open Farm also offers some extra treats for cats, such as a goat milk digestion blend with organic coconut cream, carrots, and pumpkin, to improve stomach performance. 

For dogs, customers can access the same quality food in terms of dry and wet food, including freeze-dried raw variations made specifically for dogs. 

Open Farm also offers a range of excellent treats, including wild-caught cod skins, hip, and joint supplement chews, and broths. 

There are also supplements for immunity, skin, coat support, calming, and probiotic support.

open farm cat food reviews

Open Farm Product Reviews

All of the meals and treats provided by Open Farm share the same approach to ethics, responsibility, sustainability, and quality. All ingredients are free from GMOs, antibiotics, and other unnecessary substances. 

The foods are made with human-grade components and are rich in animal-based protein, but low in fat and carbohydrates. 

Let’s take a closer look at some of the options we reviewed:

Open Farm Dehydrated Cod Skins

The crispy and crunchy dehydrated cod skins from Open Farm are made with 100% Ocean-Wise approved wild-caught cod. An excellent source of lean protein, these cod treats are great for maintaining muscle and minimizing carbs when you’re treating your pets. 

Although they’re intended for dogs, we found many of our cats loved them too!

The cod skins are dehydrated at low temperatures to maintain excellent nutrition, and all of the ingredients are 100% traceable.

The packaging is also recyclable, so you can enjoy a high level of sustainability.


  • Excellent low-carb and low-fat treat option
  • Slowly cooked to maintain excellent nutrition
  • A fantastic source of extra protein
  • No GMOs or additives


  • Not a full cat or dog food option
  • Doesn’t contain any moisture

Wild-Caught Salmon Dry Food

Ideal for pet parents who prefer giving their kitties something to graze on throughout the day, this flavor-rich dry food is a great source of DHA and omega-3 fatty acids. 

The salmon included is fully certified for ethical sustainability. The product also includes non-GMO cranberries, for extra antioxidants, vitamin C, fiber, and UTI protection. 

Other ingredients include non-GMO chickpeas for protein, copper, iron, and magnesium, pumpkin for beta-carotene and fiber, and apples for vitamin C and potassium. 

There’s also a dose of coconut oil for extra omega-9 fatty acids and fat metabolism.


  • Excellent for promoting urinary health
  • High in protein thanks to fresh salmon
  • No potato or poultry for sensitive stomachs
  • Prebiotic fibers for healthy digestion


  • No moisture for your cat’s water needs
  • Flavor may not appeal to all cats

Catch-of-the-Season Whitefish Dry Food

Another excellent high-protein kibble, the Catch of the Season whitefish dry cat food is excellent for supporting a healthy coat and skin. It’s rich in omega-3 fatty acids and DHAs and includes plenty of non-GMO greens and superfoods.  

Alongside ethically-farmed whitefish, your kitty will also get non-GMO cranberries for urinary health, chickpeas for extra fiber, pumpkin, and apples. 

This dry kibble is packed with extra health benefits thanks to non-GMO coconut oil, which assists with energy production and metabolic function. There’s no poultry or potatoes, which makes it ideal for kitties with sensitivities, and all the ingredients are traceable.


  • Simple source of animal protein for sensitive cats
  • Prebiotic fibers to improve digestion
  • No additives, GMOs, poultry, or potatoes
  • 100% sustainably sourced ingredients


  • Dry food means no moisture for kitty thirst
  • May not be ideal for some cat preferences

Open Farm Pet Food Review: pricing

The Open Farm foods are available either on a one-time purchase or subscription basis. If you sign up for a subscription, you’ll save 5% on all of your orders.

Plus, it’s worth noting all orders over $50 are available for free shipping, so if you buy plenty of food at once, you can save a little more. 

The price of each item can vary depending on what you buy.

For instance, dry food is available at $29.99 for 4LB on a one-time purchase basis or $45.99 for 4LB.

However, if you switch to auto-ship, you can pay only $28.49 for 4LB or $43.69 for 8lb. Other options include:

  • Freeze-dried foods: $9.99 for 3.5 oz or $34.99 for 13.05 oz
  • Wet food: $35.88 for a case of 12
  • Broth: $7.99 for 12 oz or $14.99 for 33.8 oz
  • Treats: Starting at $12.99 for options like dehydrated cod skins

Packages and bundles are also available. For instance, the best sellers bundle for cats is $44.95 for 12 oz of chicken broth, 1 x 4lb bag of turkey and chicken dry food, and 3 packs of rustic blend wet food. 

open farm cat foods

Open Farm Food: The Biggest Benefits

Reviewing Open Farm’s food options, we found they had a number of great benefits and very few (if any) cons. Our kitties loved the food and the treats, and our dogs enjoyed eating their delicious, freeze-dried morsels too. 

Even if you have picky animals, this company is sure to have something perfect for your pets. The biggest benefits include:

  • Ethics: All of the ingredients in the foods are sustainably sourced, with no cages or factory-farm processes. This means you can rest assured you haven’t had a negative impact on any of the creatures used to make your animal’s food.
  • Variety: There are plenty of different delicious options to choose from, including wet food, dry food, freeze-dried meals, and treats. You can also find toppers and broths ideal for giving your kitty some extra moisture during meals.
  • No artificial ingredients: All of the Open Farm foods are free from any GMOs and artificial ingredients. They’re brimming with high-quality substances and don’t contain any unnecessary grain or fillers. There are also single protein options for sensitive stomachs.
  • Simplicity: With a subscription option available, you don’t have to worry about rushing to the store every couple of weeks to stock up on extra food. You can even save money on getting everything delivered via subscription. 
  • Healthy: The foods created by Open Farm are packed full of carefully chosen ingredients designed to improve the health of your beloved pets. They support good immune system functioning, healthy skin, and fur, as well as excellent digestion.

Open Farm Review: The Verdict 

Open Farm Cat Food not only make their meals sustainable and humane, but they’re delicious too. Our kitties just couldn’t get enough of either the snacks or the dry food options. 

If you’re looking for a healthy, sustainable way to give your kitties the very best in their meals, you can’t go wrong with Open Farm. 

The company is great for dogs too! Just keep in mind, these high-quality foods might be a little more expensive than other options on the supermarket shelf. But the price is absolutely worth it when you consider what you’re getting.

Use code AFF20 for 20% off first auto-ship order!

open farm cat food product

Try this highly rated premium cat food now

About the author

Rebekah Carter is a dedicated animal lover. Her Savannah cat, Roscoe, has a lot of attitude, while her Maine Coon, Dukino, is full of love. When not writing, she’s looking after her cats and researching ways to help them live their best possible life. Her passion for animals and natural skill for writing led her to pursue pet blogging.